Report Highlights: Indian buffalo meat exports have grown to record levels in the last two years, making India the fourth country in the world to export more than 1 million tons of bovine meat annually.
As a result, CY 2013 buffalo meat exports are forecast at 2.15 million tons (on a carcass weight equivalent basis), around 30 percent over 1.66 million tons in CY 2012. CY 2011 buffalo meat exports are revised up to a record 1.29 million tons.
India’s bovine herd continues to grow in response to strong demand for dairy products, with calendar year 2013 combined stocks forecast at 327 million head and CY2012 combined stocks estimated at 323.74 million head. Indian per capita consumption remains at 2 kilograms per person, reflecting a preference for pulses, dairy, and poultry.
Livestock and Products Annual
India’s bovine herd continues to grow in response to strong demand for dairy products. Private sector investment has led to notable improvements in dairy management practices, including extension services, veterinary care, and improved genetics. Recently, rain deficit situations in parts of India (Karnataka, Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Rajasthan) have led farmers to focus on dairying when crop production failed.
Thus, herd growth is expected to continue in the short-term, with calendar year (CY) 2013 combined stocks forecast more than 1 percent over 2012 at 327 million head. CY2012 combined stocks for cattle (Bos indicus/taurus) and buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) are estimated at 323.74 million head, and CY2011 stocks have been revised upwards to 320.80 million head.
Indian buffalo meat production is growing significantly. Although no official production statistics are available, industry sources and export data indicate that continued strong export demand is triggering expansion in buffalo meat supplies in India. As a result, new slaughterhouses are emerging, providing farmers with a new market for non-productive buffalo heifers, bulls and bull calves. CY 2013 Indian buffalo meat production is thus forecast to rise to a record 4.16 million tons (on a carcass weight equivalent basis), up 14 percent from CY 2012.
CY 2012 buffalo meat production is estimated at 3.64 million tons (up 12% from CY 2011), and CY 2011 production has been slightly revised up to 3.24 million tons. Industry and government sources have indicated that cattle supplies will remain robust over the next decade, but will level off as more productive dairying technology is adopted and inefficient dairy producers exit the market.
Indian federal and state laws prohibit the slaughter of cattle for religious concerns. Buffalo slaughter is allowed, although it is restricted to bulls and unproductive heifers. Due to the profitability of meat production in India, farmers now have an incentive to salvage and sell buffalo bull calves which were previously unused.
Given this option, some farmers are fattening calves for slaughter, although the practice is still uncommon and Indian slaughter yields remain low. Production Policy The Government of India (GOI) launched The Salvaging and Rearing of Male Buffalo Calves Scheme (SRMBC) and The Utilization of Fallen Animals Scheme (UFA) under the 11th Five Year Plan (2007-2012).
The projects are funded by the National Bank for Agricultural and Rural Development and are being launched in a bid to achieve a growth rate of 10 percent for the meat sector in the 11th Five Year Plan period. The SRMBC promotes the rearing of buffalo bull calves for meat production and develops linkages with export-oriented slaughterhouses. The states of Andhra Pradesh, Bihar, Chhattisgarh,
Meat, Beef and Veal
Animal Numbers, Cattle
Jharkhand, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Orissa, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, and West Bengal are targeted as priorities.
The salvaging component of the program is expected to generate a substantial quantity of hides and other byproducts as well as provide employment in feed, fodder, meat, leather, and various input services. The UFA was developed to address high mortality rates in the Indian livestock sector. The Central Leather Research Institute has reported annual mortality of 24 million large animals and 17 million small ruminants in India.
To address this, the UFA proposes to establish carcass utilization centers in order to prevent environmental pollution, control the spread of livestock diseases, provide employment to the rural poor, and produce better quality hides and skins through timely recovery.
In addition to the SRMBC and the UFA, the GOI initiated a major program with a focus on genetic improvement entitled The National Project on Cattle and Buffalo Breeding (NPCBB) in October 2000.
Given the success of this project, the GOI decided to continue this program through the 11th Five Year Plan. Government sources indicate that the project has helped to increase both the number of crossbred animals and in-milk animals over the last decade.
A major pillar of the GOI’s livestock development strategy has been the subsidized public delivery of veterinary services. To improve the quality of these services, the Ministry of Agriculture’s Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries (DAHD) is implementing the Livestock Health and Disease Control program on a nation-wide basis, which aims to improve the diagnosis of a series of common diseases. The various components of the program are: (a) Assistance to States for Control of Animal Diseases; (b) Professional Efficiency Development; (c) National Project on Rinderpest Eradication; (d) Foot & Mouth Disease Control Program; (e) The National Control Program of Peste des Petits Ruminants; (f) The National Animal Disease Reporting System; (g) Establishment and strengthening of existing veterinary hospitals/dispensaries; and (h) National Control Program of Brucellosis.
The National Dairy Development Board (NDDB), in partnership with the Government of India and the World Bank, has developed a National Dairy Plan (NDP) in order to increase productivity of dairy animals and to provide rural milk producers with greater access to the organized milk-processing sector. The first phase of the plan, NDP 1, has a financial outlay of 416 million dollars (more than 20 billion rupees) and will be carried out between 2012 and 2017.
NDP 1 will increase dairy production through improved breeding and feeding practices as well as improved extension and management services. It will also emphasize expansion of India’s dairy cooperatives, with development of community marketing systems and a formal, organized dairy economy/sector as a top priority.
For more information on NDP refer to GAIN IN2031. The Government of India launched the National Mission for Protein Supplements in the 2011-12 Indian fiscal year, with an allocation of more than $65 million.
This mission will take up activities to promote animal-based protein production through livestock development, dairy farming, pig farming, goat rearing, and fisheries in selected blocks of the country.
India’s per capita buffalo meat consumption is estimated at approximately two kilograms per year. Increases in local consumption are marginal, reflecting population growth and India’s preference for vegetarian and dairy-based protein sources.
For non-vegetarian Indians, poultry, fish, and mutton are
the most preferred meats. As incomes grow, meat consumption increases will likely occur primarily in the poultry segment. However, as previously stated, this increase will be overshadowed by the general preference for dairy and pulses.
The rise of quick service restaurants in India is also a driver for meat consumption. However, these types of restaurants primarily focus on poultry products. For these reasons, CY 2013 buffalo meat consumption in India is forecast at 2 million tons (on a carcass weight equivalent basis), CY 2012 buffalo meat consumption is estimated at 1.98 million tons, and CY 2011 buffalo meat consumption is kept unchanged at 1.95 million tons.
Note that despite an increase in overall consumption, per capita consumption may not rise due to India’s growing population. Processing Slaughter and meat processing are now regulated by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) through The Food Safety and Standards Rules and Regulation, 2011 (FSSR).
On August 5, 2011, FSSR replaced the Meat and Meat Products Order, 1973. The FSSR contains standards and regulations for meat and meat products and requires registration and licensing of meat processors and other food operators in the meat value chain (please refer to GAIN IN2104).
FSSR also enforces sanitary maintenance and controls at all stages of meat product (including fish and poultry) production.
These standards apply to domestic and imported meat and meat products equally. For details please refer to the notifications on FSSR available at FSSAI's website. There are 33 integrated slaughter/processing facilities and 58 meat processing facilities serving the export market in India.
According to the GOI, there were 3 new export-oriented slaughter units created in 2011, (see Agricultural and Processed Food Products Export Development Authority (APEDA) approved abattoirs cum meat processing plants).
Industry sources indicate that 12 new export-oriented slaughter and processing facilities will be built by the end of 2012. Additionally, there are approximately 4000 municipal slaughter houses in India which serve the domestic market. While slaughter capacity continues to increase in India, a regulatory change in 2011 resulted in the number of APEDA-registered meat processing plants to decline from 74 to 58.
The regulation change stipulated that the “export of meat and meat products will be allowed, subject to the exporter furnishing a declaration, attached with copies of valid APEDA Plant Registration Certificate(s) to customs at the time of export that the above items (meat and meat products)have been obtained/ sourced from an APEDA-registered integrated abattoir or from APEDA-registered meat processing plant which sources raw material exclusively from APEDA registered integrated abattoir/abattoir.”
It is important to note that while exporters remain optimistic, they do not expect either new or existing slaughter facilities to produce at full capacity, primarily due to operational inefficiencies and demand limitations. Existing supply chain and value chain: Supply chains for domestic and exported buffalo meat are separate.
Only 100 percent export-oriented facilities, registered with APEDA, are eligible to produce and process meat for export purposes. Export-oriented processed meat is transported in refrigerated containers from processing units to cold storage near port locations, from where the product is shipped.
Municipal slaughter houses sell to the domestic market only. Most domestic market meat typically does not benefit from cold storage and is consumed in the locality where it is produced.
Buffalo meat production growth is being led by the export market, while domestic demand is keeping pace with the population growth rate.
Further expansion into the domestic market appears unlikely
because Indian meat retailing lacks cold chain facilities and Indian consumers prefer non-bovine proteins such as chicken, goat, dairy products, and pulses.
The Ministry of Food Processing Industries (MOFPI) launched the comprehensive financial scheme, Modernization of Existing Abattoirs, under the 11th Five Year Plan.
The program is expected to continue in the 12th Five Year Plan period (2012-2017). MOFPI is also administering another scheme for technology upgrading, establishment and modernization of processing plants. For details see http://www.mofpi.nic.in/images/ar10-11.pdf
India is a net exporter of buffalo meat (deboned frozen buffalo meat). In the last two years, exports have grown to record levels, making India the fourth country in the world to export more than 1 million tons of bovine meat annually.
India’s growing exports are the result of its low cost of production (relative to international competitors). Production costs are low due to herd growth from strong dairy demand and new incentives from slaughter facilities to salvage previously underutilized animals.
As a result, CY 2013 buffalo meat exports are forecast at 2.15 million tons (on a carcass weight equivalent basis), around 30 percent over 1.66 million tons in CY 2012. CY 2011 buffalo meat exports are also revised up to a record 1.29 million tons, based on trade data. Year-on-year export growth for 2011 is 41 percent, while 2012 growth is 28 percent.
Given its tremendous export growth, India is likely to become the world’s largest beef (buffalo meat) exporter by 2013, if not sooner. Import of beef from all sources is restricted and as such imports are set at nil. As a price-based competitor, India has seen export increases in the previous two years to Middle Eastern, African and Southeast Asian countries.
Referring to Table 1, (India: Beef Exports), the majority of export growth in 2011 was to Middle Eastern and North African Countries, although significant volumes are sold in Asia, with Vietnam as India’s largest export destination. Industry sources have stated that a similar trend is expected in 2012. While Indian buffalo meat competes on a cost basis, there are several other factors influencing trade. For example, all Indian buffalo meat is produced according to halal standards.
It is also characterized as a lean meat with positive blending characteristics. Industry sources place significant weight on India’s disease status, which includes World Organisation for Animal Health (OIE) ‘negligible risk’ classification for Bovine Spongiform Encephalopathy (BSE), and OIE ‘free’ recognition for rinderpest and Contagious Bovine Pleuropneumonia (CBP) (source: OIE). While this disease status has helped open new key markets (such as Algeria in 2010), India’s Foot and Mouth Disease (FMD) status poses issues for new market access in some countries.
Indian exporters are operating voluntary vaccination programs to combat FMD, and the GOI has launched a Rs 4,000 crore (U.S. $800 million) program to tackle the disease. While these programs are positive steps, FMD remains a significant hurdle for expanding market access. Table 1: India: Beef Exports (Metric Tons) Partner Country 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 World Total 484499 480339 434704 654985 924177 1 Vietnam 39151 92258 111166 90773 254959
2 Malaysia 52325 50553 48214 79865 96646 3 Egypt 26560 43567 28590 69779 67804 4 Saudi Arabia 35310 25599 24274 47634 62553 5 Jordan 20835 15465 12503 41742 61883 6 Philippines 51365 53036 41479 43828 47196 7 United Arab Emirates 26887 18416 16594 31757 38184 8 Algeria 30 0 0 18158 33381 9 Iran 12238 12112 5391 18023 27131 10 Iraq 5370 2982 7436 17652 23902 11 Thailand 99 77 0 3855 22996 12 Angola 47863 29870 17082 19916 21287 13 Kuwait 40315 31203 28363 36234 20619 14 Syria 0 1702 6496 13929 18838 15 Georgia 11214 8189 6563 9427 16704 16 Oman 11962 11501 8027 11351 12564 17 Congo 10576 13997 12148 12377 12472 18 Myanmar 12 0 286 19800 7684 19 Gabon 7653 6234 5837 7857 7459 20 Lebanon 5068 6448 6830 8823 7308 21 Qatar 2904 4076 4116 4624 7011 22 Azerbaijan 3271 4241 2823 3819 4974 23 Armenia 4346 5570 3717 2793 4780 24 Senegal 7825 5119 4814 5054 4262 25 Pakistan 13049 3701 2939 2967 3822 26 Ghana 9489 6425 3674 4492 3416 27 Mauritius 3361 4001 2974 3189 3348 28 Equatorial Guinea 1366 1266 1098 2056 3016 29 Bahrain 2692 2322 1932 2849 2551 30 Cote d Ivoire 5025 4176 3783 2430 2477 31 Brunei Darussalam 1641 1972 954 1231 1804 32 Yemen 3163 1368 1314 2450 1769 33 Comoros 1702 2007 1786 1945 1677 34 Tajikistan 2790 1762 2196 1681 1644 35 Uzbekistan 897 624 196 577 1608 36 Liberia 449 452 254 655 1594 37 South Africa 1 0 1 598 1539 38 Canada 0 0 0 280 1445 39 Namibia 393 1181 281 813 1291 40 Turkey 943 306 158 836 1153 41 Maldives 548 311 186 530 938 42 Afghanistan 3390 1745 464 405 838 43 Hong Kong 572 83 4063 360 802 44 China 948 630 363 27 709 45 Sierra Leone 838 503 255 263 581 46 Benin 0 58 29 316 309 47 Seychelles 53 333 219 336 266 48 Singapore 0 0 0 525 210
49 Albania 1110 1425 726 141 84 50 United States 0 121 67 193 2 51 Greece 1560 512 0 0 0 52 Mozambique 1237 57 0 252 0 53 Germany 37 12 7 450 0 54 United Kingdom 1 0 0 433 0 55 Indonesia 0 0 0 683 0 Others 4065 771 2036 1952 2687
Source: Global Trade Atlas
Source: Argentine Beef Packers S.A.
Back to News Headlines